Choose a motor yacht if you want to cover more of Italy’s coast in a week, want the extra speed and polish that comes with it, or have a budget above the luxury catamaran ceiling. Choose a catamaran if deck space, stability at anchor, and value matter more to you than distance — especially if your budget is under about €90,000 a week. In our experience, the real decision usually comes down to 4 things: your budget tier, how much route you actually want to cover, where and when you’re chartering, and which yacht type is genuinely available for your dates.
The Quick Take
- Budget tier comes first: luxury catamarans in Italy generally top out around €90,000 a week, while motor yachts start around €50,000 and scale up to megayachts with no real ceiling.
- Choose a motor yacht if: you want to cover real distance in a week, or your budget is above roughly €90,000. A motor yacht cruising at 17 knots covers roughly 2.5x the ground of a catamaran cruising at 6.5 knots in the same hours underway.
- Choose a catamaran if: your budget is under about €90,000 and deck space, stability at anchor, and value matter more than range — especially around Naples, Amalfi, and Capri in high season.
- True for both: availability isn’t even across Italy. Catamarans, and power catamarans especially, are noticeably harder to find in Sardinia, Corsica, and around Sicily. Book early if that’s the type you want there.
How Yacht Speed Changes What Your Italy Route Can Cover
Speed is the single biggest difference between the 2 yacht types, and it’s the one most comparison guides skip.
Take 2 real yachts currently chartering the same stretch of Italian coast: LUAR, an 87.6ft Sanlorenzo motor yacht, cruises at 17 knots. Lagoon Sixty5 2025, a 67ft catamaran chartering the same West Med waters, cruises at 6.5 knots. That’s roughly 2.5x the speed — and it changes what a 7-night route can actually hold.
On a motor yacht, a leg that eats half a cruising day on a catamaran becomes a comfortable hour or 2. We saw this exact effect when comparing Sicily and Sardinia: a route that’s a relaxed week on a fast motor yacht can turn into a genuine 2-week itinerary on a slower boat. If your wishlist includes more than 1 region — say, Amalfi plus a Capri and Ischia loop — the yacht’s cruising speed is often what decides whether that’s realistic in a week, more than the map distance does.
Stability and Space at Anchor
Once you’re anchored, the comparison flips.
A catamaran’s width is its real advantage — not a shallower draft, which is a common misconception. On the 2 yachts above, LUAR’s draft (1.7m) and the Lagoon’s draft (1.55m) are close enough that neither has a meaningful edge there. The catamaran’s beam, though, is 9.78m against the motor yacht’s 7.21m — nearly 40% wider — and that width is what buys you a stiller boat at anchor, more usable deck and cockpit space, and a platform most guests find easier to move around on, especially children and older guests.
We often recommend a catamaran for exactly this reason when a group plans to spend most of its time at anchor rather than covering ground — the extra beam pays off every day, not just on the crossing days.
Where Availability Actually Differs Across Italy
Choosing a yacht type in Italy isn’t only a comfort decision — it’s also an availability one, and this changes by region.
In Sardinia, Corsica, and around Sicily, catamarans — and power catamarans in particular — are a real pinch point. We’ve seen this pattern repeat across multiple seasons: searches for a catamaran or power cat in these waters routinely come up short, especially for last-minute or high-season dates. Motor yachts and monohulls are easier to find in the same regions.
If a catamaran is the yacht type you want for a Sardinia, Corsica, or Sicily charter, the practical fix is simple: start the search earlier than you would for a motor yacht in the same region. Waiting until a few months out usually means choosing from whatever is left, rather than what actually fits your group.
Budget Reality: Two Different Price Tiers
Catamaran and motor yacht aren’t just 2 different types of boat in Italy — they’re 2 different price tiers, and that’s often the real decision. Luxury catamarans generally top out around €90,000 a week. Above that, the catamaran market thins out fast, and motor yachts take over — they start around €50,000 and scale all the way up to megayachts with no real ceiling.
That gives a useful rule of thumb: if your budget is under roughly €90,000 a week and speed isn’t your priority, a catamaran is very often the better-value choice — you get a bigger boat, more deck space, and a steadier ride for the money. Above €90,000, you’re almost always choosing a motor yacht.
The exception is a handful of rare large luxury catamarans that break through that ceiling — SEAWOLF X and This Is It are 2 examples currently in the market. There are very few of these, so if one of them is what you actually want, plan to book well in advance.
This plays out at the lower end in specific hotspots too: around Naples, Amalfi, and Capri in high season, we regularly help clients recalibrate a wishlist that started with a small motor yacht in August. At that budget, the motor yacht they pictured usually isn’t available, while a catamaran of a similar size and guest count comfortably is — a catamaran here is usually the first alternative worth looking at, not a downgrade.
Which Fits Your Group Best
Families with younger children, and larger groups who want to spread out, usually lean catamaran for the same beam-and-stability reasons covered above. Couples and smaller groups who want to cover more coastline in a week — or want a higher-spec interior and larger cabins for a similar yacht length — tend to lean motor yacht.
Our Recommendation: A Simple Way to Decide
- 1. Route ambition: if you want to cover real distance or combine regions in a week, lean motor yacht.
- 2. Group comfort: if stability, deck space, and family-friendliness matter more than distance, lean catamaran.
- 3. Region and season: in Sardinia, Corsica, or Sicily, expect to book a catamaran earlier; around Naples, Amalfi, or Capri in high season, a catamaran is often the more realistic fit for the budget.
Most of our clients land on an answer once we walk through availability for their actual dates — once you apply these 3 factors, the yacht list narrows fast.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a catamaran cheaper than a motor yacht in Italy?
Usually, yes, if your budget is under about €90,000 a week — that’s roughly where the luxury catamaran market tops out, so above it you’re generally choosing a motor yacht instead. A handful of rare large luxury catamarans, like SEAWOLF X or This Is It, break through that ceiling, but they’re scarce and need to be booked well in advance.
Which is better for families with children?
Catamarans, in most cases. Their wider beam means a steadier boat at anchor and more usable deck space, which matters most with young children on board.
Are catamarans hard to find in Sardinia or Corsica?
Yes. Catamarans, and power catamarans especially, are a recurring scarcity in Sardinia, Corsica, and around Sicily. If that’s the yacht type you want in these regions, start the search earlier than you would for a motor yacht.
Can a catamaran handle open Mediterranean crossings, like Corsica to Sardinia?
Yes, but slower. A catamaran cruising around 6-7 knots turns an open crossing into a much bigger part of the day than the same route on a motor yacht cruising at 15-20 knots, so factor that into how many stops you plan for the week.
Not sure which yacht type fits your charter?
Tell us your dates, guest count, and what matters most to you. We’ll show you which motor yachts and catamarans are actually available — and help you pick the one that fits, not just the one that photographs well.
What to read next
Top 10 Crewed Luxury Catamarans for Charter in Italy 2026
How Long Should an Italy Yacht Charter Be? 7, 10 or 14 Days
Catamarans for Charter in Italy
